Current:Home > StocksWisconsin judge dismisses lawsuit challenging state’s new wolf management plan-LoTradeCoin
Wisconsin judge dismisses lawsuit challenging state’s new wolf management plan
View Date:2024-12-24 08:41:29
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — A lawsuit filed by animal welfare advocates seeking to invalidate Wisconsin’s new wolf management plan was dismissed by a judge on Monday.
Dane County Circuit Judge Stephen Ehlke threw out the case that accused Wisconsin wildlife officials of violating the state’s open meetings law and disregarding comments from wolf researchers and supporters, reflecting how contentious the debate over wolf management has become in the state.
Ehlke ruled from the bench, granting a motion to dismiss filed by the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources and its board. The lawsuit was filed by the Great Lakes Wildlife Alliance, also known as Friends of the Wisconsin Wolf & Wildlife.
The lawsuit alleged that Department of Natural Resources policy board members collected comments on the wolf management plan from interest groups it favored even after the public comment period ended.
The lawsuit focused on three private discussions attended by members of the board hosted by the Wisconsin Wildlife Federation, the Wisconsin Association of Sporting Dogs, and Wisconsin Wolf Facts.
The lawsuit alleged that even though a quorum of board members didn’t attend any of the meetings, enough of them participated to influence changes to the plan in violation of the state open meetings law.
The judge said the open meetings law did not apply to the meetings in question because there was not a sufficient number of board members present to constitute a meeting.
Ehlke also rejected allegations of due process and administrative procedure violations. The judge also rejected arguments that comments by Great Lakes Wildlife Alliance were ignored during formation of the wolf plan.
The group didn’t cite any case to back up their discrimination claims, Ehlke said. Allowing them to allege that they were discriminated against would mean that anyone could make that argument when a governmental body does something they don’t like, the judge said.
“This makes no sense to me and would cause governmental operations to grind to a halt,” the judge said.
Susann Bradford, attorney for the Great Lakes Wildlife Alliance, asked the judge to reconsider the ruling. The judge denied that request. Bradford said after the hearing that the group was reviewing whether to file an appeal.
Farmers in northern Wisconsin have complained for years that the wolf population is multiplying too quickly and preying on their livestock. Hunters say wolves are devastating the deer population across the northern reaches of the state. Conservationists argue that wolves have yet to firmly establish themselves in Wisconsin and need protection.
The DNR’s board adopted the wolf management plan in October. It recommends maintaining the statewide population at about 1,000 wolves but doesn’t set a hard limit. The plan instead recommends allowing the population to grow or decline at certain numerical thresholds.
State wildlife officials have said a lack of a hard limit gives the DNR more flexibility to manage the species, allows local wolf packs to fluctuate and gives the population a better chance at maintaining wolf abundance for years to come.
Hunting advocates support setting a population limit, saying the lack of a goal leaves both wolves and people unprotected. Conservation groups opposed a provision related to how the DNR would respond to certain population ranges in different parts of the state.
Last year, a federal judge placed gray wolves in the lower 48 states back on the endangered species list, making hunting illegal and limiting farmers to nonlethal control methods, such as fencing in livestock or using guard dogs. The DNR updated its wolf management plan in case wolves are removed from the list and hunting can resume.
The U.S. House passed a bill last week to take wolves off the endangered species list, but it is likely doomed under opposition from the Biden administration. Republicans in the Wisconsin Legislature passed a bill to require setting a specific population goal, but Democratic Gov. Tony Evers vetoed it.
veryGood! (5)
Related
- Today's Craig Melvin Replacing Hoda Kotb: Everything to Know About the Beloved Anchor
- Prince William gives rare health update about Princess Kate amid her cancer diagnosis
- Biden forgives $6.1 billion in student debt for 317,000 borrowers. Here's who qualifies for relief.
- Pentagon leaker Jack Teixeira to face military justice proceeding
- Joey Graziadei Details Why Kelsey Anderson Took a Break From Social Media
- House committee delays vote on bill to allow inmates to participate in parole hearings
- NFL draft's 15 biggest instant-impact rookies in 2024: Can anyone catch Caleb Williams?
- Police officers, guns, and community collide: How the Charlotte house shooting happened
- 'Bizarre:' Naked man arrested after found in crawl space of California woman's home
- Police sweep onto UCLA campus, remove pro-Palestinian encampment: Live updates
Ranking
- Residents urged to shelter in place after apparent explosion at Louisville business
- Police order dispersal of gathering at UCLA as protests continue nationwide | The Excerpt
- Score a Hole in One for Style With These Golfcore Pieces From Lululemon, Athleta, Nike, Amazon & More
- 'A Man in Full' review: Tom Wolfe Netflix series is barely a glass half empty
- Auburn surges, while Kansas remains No. 1 in the USA TODAY Sports men's basketball poll
- Campus protests across the US result in arrests by the hundreds. But will the charges stick?
- Say hello (again) to EA Sports College Football. The beloved video-game behemoth is back
- North Carolina Republicans seek hundreds of millions of dollars more for school vouchers
Recommendation
-
See Blake Shelton and Gwen Stefani's Winning NFL Outing With Kids Zuma and Apollo
-
A $10 billion offer rejected? Miami Dolphins not for sale as F1 race drives up valuation
-
Florida in 50 Years: Study Says Land Conservation Can Buffer Destructive Force of Climate Change
-
How to navigate the virtual hiring landscape and land a job: Ask HR
-
Mississippi Valley State football player Ryan Quinney dies in car accident
-
President Joe Biden calls Japan and India ‘xenophobic’ nations that do not welcome immigrants
-
'A Man in Full' review: Tom Wolfe Netflix series is barely a glass half empty
-
Longtime Missouri basketball coach Norm Stewart entered into the Hall of Famous Missourians